Quote Originally Posted by Billy View Post
Excellent idea! Now, how do you detect choppiness with confidence?
We have tested selling on targets and it consistently deteriorates long term cumulative performance.
Billy
This question breaks down for me to asking whether choppiness can be identified at trade pre-entry or at position post-entry. I believe that the decision to not enter on weak signals represents the first case and the accompanied belief that the expected reward isn't worth the risk (in relative terms, when compared with entering on strong signals). So now what about the second case where you already have a position and an apriori-known trade mgmt plan (which takes the form of EOD-based position exit rules, recalculated stops, etc.)

While the position is held, the market keeps on injecting new information that can be analyzed, not merely particular to the trade itself. The question I'd ask is, what would warrant altering the original trade plan and playing defense (profit taking) instead of offense (riding a trend). Is it the signal becoming neutral? Is it the position failing to "move" after X days? There's clearly a myriad of possibilities. I gather that you have tested some of them, but maybe a more dynamic market evaluation method could find that golden path of switching between offense and defense while the position is on.

$.02,

Trader D